Secondary Nav

2008 Audi R8, photo by CarGurus

Twenty Cars to Consider for Your Garage

The Youngtimer craze at Amelia Island reminded me of several cars that have caused this enthusiast many sleepless nights. Some of these models I lusted over in my teens and early twenties. A few of these Youngtimer classics already reside in Turtle Garage. Some of our picks are modern vehicles that are barely ten to fifteen years old. Most of the cars listed are actually relatively affordable (given where overall collector car prices are today). In this post, we highlight twenty vehicles that you might want to consider for your garage. All of them are rising collectibles. To keep this post succinct and on point, we have provided only three stream-of-consciousness sentences on why each car deserves your attention and consideration. (Featured Image Courtesy of CarGurus)

1994 E500, Photo by Ken Richardson

1994 Mercedes E500: Who would not want this flared beast that was the result of a rare collaboration between Porsche and Mercedes? Automobile magazine once noted that “buyers had to promise not to use it to invade Poland.” The ultimate pre-AMG sports sedan also happens to be the best sedan Mercedes ever built.

2008 Lotus Elise, photo by

2008 Lotus Elise: There is no way to have more fun on four wheels. The Lotus is a ball to drive and its Toytota engine is reliable. An affordable miniture race car in a tiny package.

1990 Porsche C4, photo by Ken Richardson

1990 Porsche 911 C4: A 959 for the masses. All-wheel drive, airbags, ABS, 3.6-liter motor, and a retractable wing all dressed in the costume of an updated but classic narrow body 911 from the ’60s. Today the 964 is the donor car for Singer….so, if it doesn’t appreciate in the years to come there is always a ready market.

1986 Mercedes-Benz 190E 16 Valve, photo by Dean Laumbach

1986 Mercedes 190E 16 Valve: Perhaps the best looking small car to be produced under Bruno Sacco’s watch. This little Cosworth four-banger was the car that launched Senna’s career when he drove the wheels off it around the Nurburgring in 1984. Good luck finding one that is not automatic and does not have one million miles.

BMW E30 M3 photo by Ken Richardson

1988 BMW E30 M3: Who can resist the flamboyant flares and oversized rear wing of this DTM ultimate driving machine? One of the most popular BMW’s is also one of the most fun to drive. Prices have hit the stratosphere for investment grade examples—but are poised to go higher still.

Mercedes-Benz CLK 63 Black Series photo by CAR Magazine

2008 Mercedes CLK 63 Black Series: Who doesn’t want a Black Series anything? This DTM race car wannabe has huge flares, a rear seat delete, and a menacing 500 hp nonturbochared motor. Only 500 were made so don’t expect to see one at your country club—Jeremy Clarkson owned one and called it “The Kin of Cain.”

1992 Dodge Viper RT/10 photo by Road and Track

1992 Dodge Viper RT/10: The brainchild of Bob Lutz. It’s a plastic modern-era Cobra with a V10 to give it legitimacy. A great story behind its birth, and a great car to look at—very cheap now and sure to rise in value over the coming years (especially the early models and the later coupes).

1989 Porsche 911 Speedster, photo by Motor1

1989 Porsche 911 Speedster: This wide-body and low-windshield 911 has a look all its own. For a modern production car, not that many were built. Yes it’s underpowered, but who cares?

BMW E46 M3, photo by Edmunds

2006 E46 M3 w/Competition Package: This car represents all that was right with BMW in the mid-2000s. A six-speed gearbox mated to a smooth six-cylinder engine combined with flared fenders, a bulging hood, and race car seats. These cars are at the top of the list for many Youngtimers.

1990 Chevrolet Corvette ZR1 photo by Hemmings

1990 Corvette ZR-1: Who didn’t want this car when it came out in the fall of 1989? Wider rear flares and a massive motor assembled far from Detroit, it was the ultimate Vette of the era. Today they can be bought for around what it costs to get over the George Washington Bridge.

1987 Buick Grand National GNX, photo by Horsepower Memories

1987 Buick Grand National GNX: Only one color: Black. Rare, boxy and mean. Every 1980s high school kid wanted one.

2001 Ferrari Maranello, photo by

2000 Ferrari 550 Maranello: A modern-era Daytona at a fraction of the price. Six-speed gated transmission. Stunning to look at and will always be so.

1991 Mercedes-Benz 560 SEC, photo by Ken Richardson

1991 Mercedes-Benz 560 SEC: Bruno Sacco’s masterpiece. This big S-class coupe says you’ve arrived—even today. Final year versions are the most desireable and are sure to appreciate in the years ahead.

1995 Porsche 928 GTS, photo by Road and Track

1995 Porsche 928 GTS: The very end of the line for the 928 brought us the most expensive Porsche ever with wide rear flares, a larger motor, and bigger brakes. This is what the 928 was meant to be from the get-go. Not a lot of them were made and most were driven hard and put away wet.

1990 Mazda Miata, photo by Dean Laumbach

1990 Mazda MX-5 Miata: The car that brought the convertible back from the dead. A reliable British roadster with German handling and Japanese reliability. Many first-generation cars are being cut up as weekend racecars….get yours soon before investment-grade examples are gone.

1987 Honda Civic CRX, photo by Curbside Classic

1987 Honda CRX Si: The CRX changed the game and made small economical cars cool. The styling is to die for and the interior is all business. The Si version had a performance edge that few econoboxes of the era could match.

1996 Nissan 300ZX Twin Turbo, photo by KBB

1996 Nissan 300ZX Twin Turbo: These were groundbreaking when they arrived in 1991. They were fabulous and comfortable to drive and carved turns like a Ginsu knife. They were also not bad to look at!

2008 Audi R8, photo by CarGurus

2008 Audi R8 4.2: This supercar came from another planet in 2008. Today it still looks futuristic. While you can get them in a more powerful V10, the 4.2 V8 has near-perfect weight distribution and is very reliable—it is a bargain supercar today.

2001 Mercedes-Benz SL 600, photo by Ken Richardson

2001 Mercedes-Benz SL600: Another Bruno Sacco masterpiece. Perhaps the most well-designed and well-built Mercedes of the modern era. No Youngtimer garage is complete without an exceptional V12 R129.

1987 VW GTI 16V, photo by Wheelsage

1987 Volkswagen GTI 16V: The original hot hatch got way hotter in 1987 with the addition of the high-revving 16-valve motor. It was a great car to drive and not bad to look at either. None have survived.

Join the conversation!

21 Responses to Twenty Cars to Consider for Your Garage

  1. Bernie Picchi May 21, 2019 at 8:47 am #

    Love the Turtle! The enduring attraction of M.B. never fails to amaze me. I am downsizing and ridding myself of an old (1994) M.B. 300E. It’s rusted body, no a/c, and defunct radio and tape player (yes!!!) are defunct – but there is no absence of interest from buyers in this old beauty.

  2. Michelle March 30, 2019 at 2:27 am #

    Early Subaru WRX STI.

    • Philip Richter March 30, 2019 at 10:07 pm #

      Thanks for your feedback. See our most recent post where we added your suggestion. Thank you! —TG

  3. Scott March 26, 2019 at 10:58 am #

    To this list and the cars mentioned by others I would add the Honda S2000. It was a technological marvel when it was introduced, is a single generation (admittedly two sub-generations) and was the best of Honda at a time Honda was at its best – when Honda engineers were bold, confident and innovative. Because it also has traditional Honda virtues, the S2000 is dead reliable and cheap to maintain, making annual ownership costs a fraction of traditional exotics. Plus, it is just flat out a blast to drive!

    • Philip Richter March 30, 2019 at 10:08 pm #

      Thanks for your thoughtful comment. Yes, the S2000 should be on our list! See our most recent post for some additional cars based on reader feedback. Thank you for your suggestion! —TG

  4. toly arutunoff March 25, 2019 at 7:46 pm #

    you overlook the price/performance/performance/serviceability combo of at least the decade: the Qvale Mangusta. the best one in the country is well under $40k. exclusive, quick, and serviceable at a ford dealership. and it even won the 2001 trans-am series! even with the stupid scca rules mandating a change from irs to a live rear axle…

    • Philip Richter March 30, 2019 at 10:09 pm #

      I need to get better educated! I know nothing about this car and will start doing some research! Thank you! —TG

  5. Jack March 25, 2019 at 5:08 pm #

    I have a 2007 Shelby GT500 convertible, and I would take it over any of those cars except the R8 and the Maranello, both of which cost a multiple of the Shelby.

    • Philip Richter March 30, 2019 at 10:10 pm #

      The GT 500 is a beast. See our recent post where we added some cars based on reader feedback. We had a lot of suggestions to add the 1993 SVT. —TG

  6. Bob Kahrl March 25, 2019 at 1:24 pm #

    I forgot to mention another possible American collectible. The 2000 Plymouth Prowler was the last year of the “Plymouth” nameplate and a really oddball car it is. The colors were great. A collector would want one with the matching trailer that could be ordered to make up for the minimal cargo space. I have wondered whether this would ever become collectible, but the farther it recedes into the past, the more I think it will eventually become collectible. It is, after all, eye-catching, and nobody in my neighborhood has one. Indeed, I haven’t seen one on the road for years.

  7. Bob Kahrl March 25, 2019 at 12:19 pm #

    Your list seems very German-oriented to me. I think a lot of younger men would lust after an Acura NSX and the more knowledgeable ones would also go for the Subaru SVX with the unique side-window treatment and body by Giugiaro. So those two cars would restore a little balance to the list. As a runner-up, the 2002 Mazda RX-7 was the best of its line with a rotary engine making it uniquely collectible. It seems that younger men (and also women) do not have the “must come from Europe” bias of us older enthusiasts. To them, great cars often came out of Japan.

    • toly arutunoff March 25, 2019 at 7:40 pm #

      I had a front wheel drive six and a ’94 rx/7 with a catback and cold air intake. fantastic performance. I’ve never ever driven a more comfortable and quieter ride than the sea. and with left foot braking it’ll get around corners quite well, thank you!

      • Philip Richter March 30, 2019 at 10:09 pm #

        See our current post where we added your suggestion of the RX-7. —TG

    • Philip Richter March 30, 2019 at 10:11 pm #

      Thank you for your comments. See the current post which adds your picks on the NSX and RX-7. Thank you! —TG

  8. ceeberg55 March 25, 2019 at 10:18 am #

    Another great read–I like the short and sweet comments on each model, and I like expanding the palette of collectibles for a younger generation of gearheads.

    • Philip Richter March 30, 2019 at 10:12 pm #

      Thank you for your positive feedback and for being a reader of TG. —TG

  9. GLK March 25, 2019 at 8:25 am #

    When it comes to 80s collectibles the Alfa Romeo GTV6 is the consummate, “Oh, yeah, that’s right!” car.

  10. JK of Miami March 25, 2019 at 4:28 am #

    Great read Philip.
    Consider adding the 1989-1991 Callaway Corvette Twin Turbo w/ aero body.
    A regular production option (“RPO”) that you could check off at the Chevy dealer as a “B2K” for an additional ~$30,000. They were extremely powerful ( 400 hp/ 575 tq) and the fastest convertibles you could buy.

    They were the street version of the famous “Sledgehammer” car that did 254 MPH in 1988.

    • Philip Richter March 30, 2019 at 10:13 pm #

      That sounds like a beast. I need to do some research on that relationship with Callaway. Seems like a lot of upgrade for $30,000! —TG

      • Greg Lemon October 7, 2019 at 11:56 pm #

        Love your list, but would also agree it is a little German heavy, the CRX Si is an excellent add to the list, and one of those unique cars that was on the lower end of the price scale when new, but through high quality engineering and enough enthusiasts that see it’s appeal, has survived at a much higher than average rate, but not so high as to keep it from appreciating.

        I will suggest a few Japanese cars I think could be on the list. Mazda Eunos Cosmo three rotor turbo–ultimate Japanese bubble era car, three rotor twin turbo Wankel engine, touch screen and navigation in 1990. At the opposite end of the spectrum the original Honda Insight with a clarity of purpose rarely seen and MPG rarely surpassed.


  1. Reader Feedback: A Few to Grow On | Turtle Garage - March 30, 2019

    […] week’s post “Twenty Cars to Consider for Your Garage” generated an enormous amount of reader feedback. The cars we listed were subjective but carefully […]